US Citizens Told to Be Ready to Prove Citizenship During ICE Enforcement

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is facing scrutiny after reports that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents have been asking people in enforcement areas to show identification or proof of citizenship.

DHS Secretary Kristi Noem defended the practice as part of what she described as “targeted enforcement”. She said officers may seek to confirm the identity and intentions of individuals near enforcement activity, and that arrests may follow if violations of the law are discovered during these checks.

Her comments followed allegations that Americans, including protesters, were asked to provide identification during ICE operations. Tensions have been heightened in Minnesota, where demonstrations intensified after the fatal shooting of US citizen Renee Nicole Good by an ICE agent.

Civil liberties groups argue that the practice risks breaching constitutional protections. They note that US citizens are not legally required to carry identification and that demanding it without specific cause may violate the Fourth Amendment’s protection against unreasonable searches and seizures.

In a post on X, DHS rejected claims of arbitrary enforcement, stating that its actions are based on immigration status rather than race or ethnicity. The department said arrests are carried out under the principle of “reasonable suspicion”, which it says is supported by Supreme Court rulings.

Video footage from Minneapolis and other cities shows residents objecting to officers’ demands for identification. Legal analysts say officers may request ID when issuing a citation or making an arrest, but generally cannot compel a person to produce documents without reasonable suspicion of a crime. However, a refusal to cooperate may lead to temporary detention if officers believe unlawful activity may be involved.

Federal officials have also said ICE agents have faced interference from individuals claiming to be legal observers, prompting some requests for identification. Several people have been detained in recent weeks on suspicion of obstructing Border Patrol and ICE operations.

Different rules apply to non-citizens and lawful permanent residents. Under Section 264(e) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, non-citizens aged 18 and over must carry proof of registration at all times, such as a green card, employment authorisation document, or Form I-94. Failure to do so can result in fines or up to 30 days in prison.

In October 2025, the Trump administration instructed enforcement agencies to impose penalties or revoke lawful permanent resident status for repeated non-compliance, signalling a tougher approach to immigration enforcement.

The issue reflects ongoing tension between enforcement practices and constitutional rights. 

Community groups, including Native American organisations, say the policy recalls past experiences of disproportionate questioning and surveillance. DHS maintains that its actions remain within legal limits as demonstrations continue in several cities.