Eliud Kipchoge’s Sub-Two-Hour Marathon Record is Fake, US-Based Kenyan Lawyer Makau Mutua Says

Eliud Kipchoge’s Sub-Two-Hour Marathon Record is Fake, US-Based Kenyan Lawyer Makau Mutua Says

US-based Kenyan lawyer Prof. Makau Mutua has poked holes at athlete Eliud Kipchoge’s sub-tw0-hour marathon record set last month.

Kipchoge made history when he completed the 42-kilometer race in 1 hour 59 minutes 40 seconds in Vienna, Austria on October 12th, becoming the first man to run a marathon in less than two hours.

In an opinion piece published in Sunday Nation, Prof. Mutua opined that Kipchoge's fuss that no human is limited is misleading. 

The Kenyan-American scholar argued that conditions favored 34-year-old Kipchoge to complete the INEOS 1:59 Challenge within the duration. 

He noted that Kipchoge had pacesetters who were friendly to him unlike in the real marathon contest where one is surrounded by rivals. 

He dismissed the assertion that no human is limited, saying that the argument is unfounded and senseless.

"He ran against himself without having to be worried — or psyched out — by real competitors. Instead, he was escorted by friendly 'sycophants' brought there to help him break the two-hour barrier,” wrote Mutua.

He continued: “ It’s like a boxer who knocks out a hapless sparring partner. Or a dictator running against himself.”

“So, in a sense Mr. Kipchoge’s 'record' is fake. The first true under-two-hour marathon hasn’t been run yet," he asserted.
 

Comments

FUNDI (not verified)     Tue, 11/12/2019 @ 10:20pm

In reply to by Gilbert Masitsa (not verified)

There was no claim it was a world record. The organizers were very clear that he would be running alone (no competitors) except for the pace setters and they even said it is not an official record. Keep in mind that Kipchoge holds the official marathon world record which is a mere 1 min 59 seconds longer than his "personal" record

Peter (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 12:33pm

True. It was fake that is why it was not recognised as a normal record. It was a controlled marathon. However, he ran anyway and completed under two hours..I think the organisers are the ones who ought to have come out honestly and expressly make it clear to everyone that it was not a normal race. I think they kind of made it look like a normal race. They were not honest. The company; INEOS has continued to take advantage of the race in subsequent tweets propagating the 1:59 fete. They were not honest right from the beginning.

formerlyguest2 (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 05:48pm

In reply to by Peter (not verified)

I believe they were if you were following this from 2 years ago. They clearly explained the course, the use of pace makers which is not "normal" in regular marathons, and if you are talking of the "shoes" lol , it provided nothing. Kipchoge ran the full race with no aide - no on lifted him, ran for him, took breaks etc. if you are runner which I suspect you and Mutua are not , then you would not even know what a fete that was . Try running a marathon and then discrete 1:59 or even 3 hrs for you :-)

Hamee (not verified)     Tue, 11/12/2019 @ 11:29am

In reply to by Peter (not verified)

This is utter nonsense. In what way was the organisers misleading when clearly they reliably informed us of their intentions? They clearly stated that this was done to demonstrate that no human was limited and that its possible (with the right conditions ofc) to break the 2 hour window. They also went as far and stated their strategy to accomplish such a milestone, so I can't possibly see how they mislead us. Kopchoge is by fsr the most decorated Marathoner in history;we can't question his capability and mental fortitude. So for his fellow country man to try to discredit this historical accomplishment on the basis of the set parameters used to accomplish such is very distasteful because had we put any other marathon runner in that event they would've crumbled.

FUNDI (not verified)     Tue, 11/12/2019 @ 10:27pm

In reply to by Peter (not verified)

Do you guys understand the meaning of fake. He RAN the marathon, nothing fake in that. Is it fake because he did not compete with anyone. Or because he wore special shoes, or the perfect weather or track. The organizers were actually very clear that it was not a competition. Were you guys paying any attention. We need to give Kipchoge hongera for making Kenya proud. Maintaining a pace of 4.35 min/mile for almost 2 hours is mid blowing.

DANIEL KOMEN (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 01:54pm

ok, this fool should round up his folks and go do the same with that bald head of his. nonsense, what a MORON. KUMBAFF

DANIEL KOMEN (not verified)     Mon, 11/11/2019 @ 07:33pm

In reply to by Charles Muthama (not verified)

Muthama, im not here to look for clout, just because a member of your tribe said something stupid don't take it in and be all good. this dude isn't an athletics specialist or anything like that, simple, he can get his village friends and go recreate this fete. pumbavu yeye.

Maxiley (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 02:19pm

Mr. Mutua, if you are yearning for attention, there are better ways of getting it.You are just about the only one who is reading this INEOS project result negatively.
What you are asserting here is not new,except that your language is malicious,and Anti-Kipchoge.
You seen to think that any dick-head would have done what Kipchoge did.I even doubt that you are a sports fan.What do you mean by "pace makers were friendly" to Kipchoge? Well did you expect adversarial relationship amongst them? They paced according to plan,and executed that plan to perfection.
For your own information, what no human is limited means that there is no preset level or limit to be reached.Of course Kipchoge is not stupid to think that one can run a marathon in one hour.
I think we should look into how you acquired your academic credentials.They way you think does not jive with the scholastic achievement you claim to have.
Let KIP enjoy his accolades in peace.Yes he got the president's attention,and you did not.Even Obama commented on his historic achievement.
Go dont let your sour grapes choke you.

formerlyguest2 (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 05:50pm

In reply to by Maxiley (not verified)

Maxiley I proudly say Kicphoge BROKE A RECORD! Now let's see Mutua running NYC marathon next year and see how many hours it will take him to even make 5 hrs . Please he needed to shut up and stop pouring cold water on something all runners knows too well that what Kipchoge did was amazing. I try to ran and key word is try and it is HARD!

Michael Imbiru (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 03:25pm

Hi Proff, please don't be like Miguna who doesn't see anything good from his motherland, be the good prof you've always been and cheer our legend for the accomplished task, given,nobody could have done it even under those 'friendly'circumstances

mwangi (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 04:37pm

This is the same guy who vowed he would never acknowledge Uhuru as president of Kenya. He then goes ahead and applies for the position of Chief Justice. That's hypocricy.

In this instance you are peeing on the parade, Seems you cant bare to see somebody else enjoy the limelight. You may have a deep rooted psychological problem.

Mzee (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 04:59pm

You are dumber than a rock. He wasn't competing against people but he put all the conditions favourable to beat the 2 hour mark.

Maxiley (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 08:17pm

In reply to by formerlyguest2 (not verified)

This word"fake" is being badly abused. Mr. Mutua,there is nothing fake about what Eliud accomplished. It would only be fake if along the way somebody gave him aride,or if he rode a horse - part of the way.
I watched the whole race,and the distance was not truncated... in addition,Kipchoge's feet where on the ground from start to finish.He was running.
You probably watched the race under the influence.Still that's no excuse.By now you should have cleared your head and reviewed the race,instead of spewing falsehood.
I ask,what really prompted you to write this nonsense? The only thing that comes to my mind is that you are envious of the attention Eliud is getting-palling with presidents,and millionaires.Come on be happy for him.That was damn hard work.You try it.

Mike Porter (not verified)     Sun, 11/10/2019 @ 11:46pm

No one stated the event was a race.
The improper description of the pacers shows running ignorance. I don't know if this Kenyan lawyer ever raced but I did. My opinion is the pacing does not help as much as proposed. We runners know how to Pace n race and I don't care who is in the race. I react to my form n my goals.
What was the goal?
To see if it was physically possible for a human to run 13.1 miles per hour for two hours. It was this proven. End of story.
Shoes? Great....some guys I used to race shoes won't help them at all.... their talent is the controller.
The whole economic role of superior shoes is called Capitalism.
Pace marks? Nice but only marginally helps. A runner who is "on" knows what he is doing and I really doubt Kip worried much about lights.
Ohh, is all of cycling who utilize the peloton and drafting and top scientifically designed bicycles all fraud now.
Kip has good competition and his uncanny range from a mile (World 1500m champ) to marathon is rare. Kip n his competition will someday break 1:59 in a race because they have the talent.
I hope this lawyer replies with his running back ground or I suggest he do some "field research" and RACE

Nancy Kariru. (not verified)     Mon, 11/11/2019 @ 02:34am

Mutua are you attacking kipchoge or the Kalenjins? And why now after kibra elections? There is a difference between a cooperate vision and a personal vision. He proved he had a personal vision and achieved it. Do you have any and what have you achieved. Usipake kenya matope. Kaa America the land of the dead. Soon you will regret why you sought refuge there.

Frank (not verified)     Mon, 11/11/2019 @ 03:07am

Any Kenyan with two same names and he is in exile from a country which has no civil war is a cheap cheater. And it's not wise to keep listening or reading their poems. The MM's

Joel Kiplimo (not verified)     Mon, 11/11/2019 @ 09:44am

Don’t listen to this fool Kipchoge wasn’t competing with anyone but time try even with one mile we see buree kabisa

Douglas Wamburu (not verified)     Mon, 11/11/2019 @ 11:49am

I had some little respect left for you but that’s evaporated completely now. You are a disgrace to the human race. I dare say a psychopath with an over exaggerated sense of self. Shame on you for attacking a dignified Kenyan hero, a father, a husband and a respected sportsman world over. Have you ever run a marathon in your life? Try and prove that you do at least 30 minutes. Buffoon wewe. I pity your students if you have any that is.

Kujipanga Kibowen (not verified)     Mon, 11/11/2019 @ 02:22pm

I hate to be this idiot's student. He is either ignorant or high on weed! M.M claims to be a prof; no idea in what field but based on his last articles I am tempted to believe he ain't what he is! When E. Kipchoge signed up for 1:59 INEOS; anyone who was curious to find out about it, read and understood that the event was MAN vs TIME!
Kipchoge vs time (under 1:59) given all parameters kept constant if possible.
This fool Makau Mutua just woke up from his nap or alcohol or drugs and thinks he knows too much. Go back to your drugs idiot or if it bothers you too much get your fat ass and go to Dicks and grab some track and field outfit(that's if you find one that fits you) and sign up for your own under 1:59, i promise to watch you pass out before you hit a mile MORON!

Orde (not verified)     Tue, 11/12/2019 @ 11:55am

Well all those IAAF world records accomplished in the diamond league that have pacers are fake as well,is this the argument being popularized here?
Human achievement should always be gloried. I wonder if other marathoners given the same conditions can accomplish this? Also in the diamond league these runners run one race unlike other competitions like olympics,world,commonwealth, etc does this mean these runners have an unfair advantage and should not be credited with world records?

Aidan Arthur (not verified)     Tue, 11/12/2019 @ 01:48pm

While everyone involved in this project was aware that it wouldn't be an official record, it's still amazing that he was able to run that distance in under two hours. There's no need to call it "fake."

Xolani (not verified)     Wed, 11/13/2019 @ 03:59am

Some people dont even follow anything from implimantation and the stages up to the final day.You here people saying they were misled by Ineos.From that on it's own ir shows that the person is clueless,why argue with that person.What I know my hero broke his own record and that's final.You can say whatever you want say.If you dont have something positive to say just shut up.

Anthony Paul Farley (not verified)     Wed, 11/13/2019 @ 04:45am

My brilliant Harvard Law School classmate and friend, Makau Mutua, is a scholar, not an athlete! Usually he's insightful, but he's way off the mark on this one. Kipchoge holds both marks, the real WR and this sub-2. No one is confusing the sub-2, run behind a wind-blocking truck and a group of the world's next-best professional distance runners, with the legitimate world record of 2:01:39 that Kipchoge set winning the 2018 Berlin marathon. But his Vienna sub-2 was still an awe-inspiring achievement. Running 4:33 per mile for 26.2 miles is absolutely astonishing! Ask the best competitive runner you know how long he can maintain a 4:33 per mile pace and you'll learn why Kipchoge's competitors are also his greatest admirers!

FUNDI (not verified)     Wed, 11/13/2019 @ 01:22pm

In reply to by Anthony Paul Farley (not verified)

@Anthony. Thanks for putting it Succinctly. These are simple facts that the good prof is either ignoring or was not aware of. Why not just celebrate the achievement. I ran as well and Kip's pace in my book is the stuff of legends. Runners understand how great this achievement was and it is something to be admired and not trashed.

Charles (not verified)     Mon, 11/18/2019 @ 10:47am

This is another statistic about a house nigga feud on a field nigga scenario. Why should the cretics come from within the house. We know very well time and again as Napoleon said it better that history is a set of lies agreed upon. Let’s be proud of our story period.

Add new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
CAPTCHA
2 + 3 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.